I meant while considering Murli points also, not just in isolation. Because those who raise the DOB issue have taken base as Murli points. So, have they been able to explain all the other Murli points related? -FB wrote:I am sorry but it has already been solved by some PBKs via official sources.
Post No. 84- http://www.brahmakumarisforum.net/chat/ ... 110#p11850
From this viewpoint, I meant it cannot be solved.
But, a wonderful thing in Drama is, see the karma philosophy here. It is PBKs who have raised this question. And they themselves have been caught in the great error in DOB of their own Guru/Father. Already put in the forum- viewtopic.php?f=39&t=2593&p=48745&hilit=february#p48745.
I also believe it was not rigid. Then why for you or PBKs DOB of B Baba is an issue?* Just by taking isolated Murli points?My understanding of the four ashrama (stages) of human life, is that it was more to do with what you had done - e.g. fulfilled your responsibilities and learnt or mastered - rather than your specific age. It was not rigid and there were variances in the practice.
This is what I had said- no one (who refers to Murli) can solve the issue of DOB of B Baba.But we are stuck with the Murlis where it does say a specific age, and so have to square that with the facts.
No. Because when the Supreme Father, teacher, and Guru is there, what is the need of lowkik education? Even without that one can go ahead. For example, Mama, and many Dadis, Didis, etc., have achieved a great level without lowkik education in Yagya, which have made them popular even in front of the world. There are enough surrendered brothers in Yagya who are well respected by the Brahmin family. So, if the 10 year child had practiced BK philosophy, he would have very good status, could have earned great love, respect in BK Yagya later.Having a 10 year old child would definitely preclude you from doing so.
It may look like fun to you. Jaisee drushti, vaisee srushti. There were lots of obstacles, which they had to face. Yes, it was also spiritual bliss for all, to many children there, not just to B Baba. But, what to do? more than 80% failed.We need to know more about how Lekhraj Kirpalani treated his son during this period when he was having so much fun for himself.
And, the one child of B Baba (mostly Narayan Dada, who left Yagya during beggary period, mostly he could be the same 10 your old child during 1936/32, not sure, you may check), after leaving Yagya, made lot of money, and later after coming to Madhuban, said to Dadis- "I did not recognize my Father to the level you have recognized." I have heard this from others. He visits Madhuban every Jan 18 since many years.
So, directly or indirectly ShivBaba had returned him.
*-A very important question- You believe DL cheated all others, and Murlis were words of just DL, (later edited by his followers). If so, how can DL/Murli say "I/God entered in this when he was 60 yrs old?", that too at many places? Why or how can they do such an error even by mistake? A simple logic which goes against many of your accusations or research.
If you do not have enough time, no need to reply. Left to you.